Karl Herrup (@karlherrup) 's Twitter Profile
Karl Herrup

@karlherrup

Solving all of human disease in alphabetical order Alzheimer's, ataxia-telangiectasia, autism. Professional iconoclast. International outlook. Politics separate

ID: 2604483043

calendar_today05-07-2014 01:07:30

950 Tweet

2,2K Followers

2,2K Following

Karl Herrup (@karlherrup) 's Twitter Profile Photo

The point of this montage was not to suggest facial features can be used as a "clock". My point was we are sensitive to age as a "feature" of someone. I gave only 6 ages as options; that constrains the response. Looking only at one panel, estimates could reasonably vary by ยฑ20%

Madhav Thambisetty (@madhavthambiset) 's Twitter Profile Photo

1/n Thoughts on Neurofilament Light (NfL) as a neurodegeneration biomarker. I expect to hear a lot on it in the upcoming #Tofersen Adcom. U.S. FDA refers to it as a promising biomarker of neurodegeneration in several diseases at the Relyvrio #ALS approval๐Ÿ‘‡Robert Howard Ash Paul

1/n Thoughts on Neurofilament Light (NfL) as a neurodegeneration biomarker. I expect to hear a lot on it in the upcoming #Tofersen Adcom. <a href="/US_FDA/">U.S. FDA</a> refers to it as a promising biomarker of neurodegeneration in several diseases at the Relyvrio #ALS approval๐Ÿ‘‡<a href="/ProfRobHoward/">Robert Howard</a> <a href="/pash22/">Ash Paul</a>
Karl Herrup (@karlherrup) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Lecanemab is neither safe nor effective for Alzheimer's patients: Against the FDA approval - Sign the Petition! chng.it/bKSSzkD2 via Change.org In my opinion we are going down a dangerous road. We need to consult our maps and re-orient ourselves. Please consider signing.

Jessica Adams (@rxrega) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Is there an FDA-approved drug to maintain mental function in Alzheimer's? I see this tweet from FDA (pic) and did a double take to ask this question. Where I'm coming from I know the recent beta-amyloid drugs are still pending clinical outcomes. I thought at most you could say

Is there an FDA-approved drug to maintain mental function in Alzheimer's? I see this tweet from FDA (pic) and did a double take to ask this question. 
Where I'm coming from I know the recent beta-amyloid drugs are still pending clinical outcomes. I thought at most you could say
Karl Herrup (@karlherrup) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Help me out here. If AD is defined by amyloid then you canโ€™t have *any* stage of the disease without amyloid. Mutations in Mapt show that you can have tau-driven dementia. But these dementias are not AD by definition. So isnโ€™t this a bit of circular logic?

Karl Herrup (@karlherrup) 's Twitter Profile Photo

We agree. I made the tau comment mostly because I worry about the fuzzy way we define AD (made even worse by Jacks presentation at #AAIC23 ). We are quick to ascribe causality to correlation and need to be more careful.

Karl Herrup (@karlherrup) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Some of us might take issue with characterizing it as โ€œpretty solidโ€. I actually wrote an entire book unpacking the evidence and while there were a few sticks left standing here and there, the evidence in support of the current biomarkers came away looking flimsy at best.