Abdul Rahman (TAP)
@abdul_now
Panellist on the Thought Adventure Podcast
ID: 1360244826004930564
https://youtube.com/c/ThoughtAdventurePodcast 12-02-2021 15:10:26
4,4K Tweet
7,7K Takipçi
286 Takip Edilen
Abdul Rahman (TAP) Dr. Shadee Elmasry Muhammad Yasir Al-Hanafi Jake Brancatella To cite "Jaʿal" as an evidence for creation is what the Jahmiyyah did 12 centuries ago, as mentioned "Kitāb al-Ḥaidah" of al-Kināni. As for "Muhdath", it doesn't necessarily mean created; this is what Imam al-Dunya Muhammad b. Ismaeel al-Bukhari had to say:
May Allah reward Muhammad Yasir Al-Hanafi for the honest and direct answer. “That’s what it means to be an action…to be created.” So according to the Ashari school, Allah does not have an “Act of speaking” that is His attribute. Shams Tameez, someone who supposedly teaches Kalam, said
I appreciate Sh Muhammad Yasir Al-Hanafi’s effort to reconcile the apparent conflict here, but it unfortunately does not address the issue at hand. The prior meaning being a condition for action does not make it itself an action, so let’s first get that out of the way. Secondly, I’m
Capturing Christianity So you think God eats? If you don’t, then let me rephrase it in the only language you understand: P1: All beings that eat food are non-divine. P2: Jesus ate food. C: Jesus is non-divine.