Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profileg
Edward Hunter Christie

@EHunterChristie

Senior Research Fellow @FIIA_fi.
PhD @VUBrussel & Belgian Royal Military Academy.
Former @NATO official 2014-2020.
Views my own.

ID:935445678490374144

linkhttps://www.linkedin.com/in/edward-hunter-christie/ calendar_today28-11-2017 09:50:04

27,8K Tweets

31,3K Followers

2,1K Following

John Spencer(@SpencerGuard) 's Twitter Profile Photo

The UN should do a general assembly vote that Russia’s decision to reestablish a blockade on all Ukrainian ports is illegal & that an international peacekeeping force will be put in the Black Sea to establish corridors. Without Ukraine’s food millions around the world will die!!

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

A pro-Kremlin action by, it seems, one young man with well-scripted lines - with our friend Max here further specifying the key lies to propagate.
Not the 1st time they film in such a way that we hear the agit-prop lines loud & clear, the counters less so.

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Italy, too, recently joined the real Champions League: Allies who deliver M270 Multiple Launch Rocket Systems (similar to HIMARS) and self-propelled howitzers, to Ukraine. APCs, a key need, were also in the package that was decided by the previous govt.

ukrinform.net/rubric-defense…

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Quality over quantity, young man, quality over quantity. That means you and your vulgar acts of propaganda on behalf of hostile foreign powers should not be welcome. It appears the management of The Hill has chosen wisely.

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Not for me to work through this, but my hot take:
1: unacceptable for a foreign power to have de-facto police stations in our nations, they need to go
2: get the CCP out of our politics
3: our intel agencies must speak out & inform

Lost trade in retaliation = price worth paying

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

A warning for all of us.
Agree or disagree with the details of Elbridge Colby's diagnosis, no European government should dismiss the emerging threat pattern he highlights, and what it could do to our alliances and mutual dependencies.

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Typical SPD.
The mental blockages preventing simple rational thought - namely, the other big powers owe us nothing and might screw us too, the only way to get Putin to behave is force - run so deep, and the associated magical thinking so strong, that they come up with this.

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

-but it's also possible that UK/US estimates have a small downward bias for reasons of analytical and political prudence
-at this time, there is no compelling case for assuming that Ukraine's estimates shouldn't be used
-but a compelling case for ignoring Russian claims

20-20

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Bearing in mind leaks from RUS and previous UK estimates, the sensible conclusion is:
-RUS lies about its KIA by a factor of 5 to 10, making its claims unusable
-Ukraine's estimates of Russian KIA may have a small upward bias

19-20

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

But the notion that Ukraine exaggerates RUS KIA by a factor of 5 to 10 is completely false. As I showed in tweet 9, assuming a perfect UK estimate in late June, the exaggeration would have been 42% at that time.

18-20

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

With the Russian state, we actually know that they minimize their own casualties by a ridiculous factor, indeed 5 to 10. On 21 Sept. Shoigu claims 5,937 KIA at a time when the true figure is highly likely well above 25K (UK June est.), maybe 55K (Ukraine est.)

17-20

With the Russian state, we actually know that they minimize their own casualties by a ridiculous factor, indeed 5 to 10. On 21 Sept. Shoigu claims 5,937 KIA at a time when the true figure is highly likely well above 25K (UK June est.), maybe 55K (Ukraine est.) 17-20
account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Mr. Roepcke also makes it sound as if both sides had an identical behaviour on this matter. Of course that's not true at all: the Russian state is a more unhinged liar than almost any other state in our planet's history. Ukrainians are smarter than that.

16-20

account_circle
Edward Hunter Christie(@EHunterChristie) 's Twitter Profile Photo

Doing so would have yielded 15K KIA as of 20 July, in fact the CIA Director's statement states that very figure, which is already higher than Mr. Roepcke's 12K estimate. And then there's over 3 full months of intense fighting to add to take us from 20 July to today.

15-20

account_circle