Tony Ross-Hellauer Vincent Traag Ludo Waltman Lex Bouter F1000Research Open Research Europe eLife - the journal And this is where things get interesting for me - versioning and version of records has been our biggest battle with indexers. As a first mover we have had dance the dance to meet their journal shaped rules. Hopefully this move makes them see beyond indexation of a final version!

We asked eLife - the journal what doing away accept/reject meant for retractions. 'If a Reviewed Preprint is found to be fraudulent or deeply flawed, we will retract it, with a notice.'

Trends in Peer Review of Preprints: A panel discussion on 10/26 at 15:00 UTC with arXiv’s scientific director Steinn Sigurðsson and speakers from Maynooth University Aalto University ASAPbio Register here: cornell.zoom.us/webinar/regist… #OAWeek

Georg Henning I sign all my reviews even though I'm an ECR. Sometimes scary but IMO always worth it for me:
-I'm accountable for what I say
-I want the author to know who I am so they can weigh my comments within the context they emerge from
Note that I'm in metascience...

Thrilled to see and listen to Gracielle Higino and Silvio Peroni today at the #PublishYourReviews ASAPbio community call happening now.

What advice do you have for #ECRs who want to participate in publishing their reviews?
Gracielle: discuss a #preprint in a journal club & use the discussion as the review
Silvio: what is the advantage of not posting? The goal is to advance science & sharing reviews enables this

If you want to post your review on a #preprint , is there a concern about the confidentiality of the review process at the journal?
Silvio: you are reviewing a preprint, this is already publicly available.

#PublishYourReviews

Gacielle & Silvio note that authors like to have their #preprints reviewed, the responses they have received have been positive.

#PublishYourReviews

Silvio highlights that value in raising awareness among editors about the possibility of posting reviews open, he is now getting more positive responses noting they are willing to look at information about ongoing initiatives

Silvio Peroni
#PublishYourReviews

How to get going with posting reviews publicly?

Gracielle highlights the value of using PREreview resources to write her first open reviews.

Silvio notes he pays particular care when preparing the public review, to ensure it is as clear as possible.

#PublishYourReviews

Open peer reviews have many benefits - importantly they provide a way of acknowledging this important activity. It also means the reviewer needs to take responsibility for their comments
Silvio Peroni

#PublishYourReviews

Reviewing #preprints allows researchers to have a conversation about the science
Gracielle Higino

#PublishYourReviews

There are so many exciting developments around open science and peer review; very much looking forward to my talk 'Open access and beyond – Peer review in the age of open science' next week at UAntwerpen Raf Guns

Keynote of our AII2022 workshop - a physiological thinking on the trade-offs between connectionist and symbolic AI. Really insightful and inspiring! Thank you, Ludo Waltman